Rare Book Monthly

Articles - November - 2023 Issue

Library Sale Turns into Library Theft

The poster was a bit vague and subject to different interpretations.

The poster was a bit vague and subject to different interpretations.

The Batley Library in Wales, U.K., saw dozens, maybe hundreds of books taken from its shelves in one of the more bizarre misunderstandings seen lately. The Friends of the Batley Library were holding a book sale to help fund raise for a campaign to save their over a century old Carnegie Library. They created a poster announcing “Fill-A-Bag” Book Sale on Friday October 6 and Saturday October 7. For £1 (about $1.20) you could fill up a bag of books to keep “and that's it!!!” It turned out there was a lot more to it than meets the eye.

 

All went well on Friday. However, that evening, some people posted a misinterpretation on social media. The Friends had a table of books from which to make a purchase. Some posters thought that the library was permanently closing and disposing of all their books. So, they posted that for £1 a bag, you could take any books off the library shelves. The people came, filled up their bags with books that were not for sale and belonged to operator Kirklees Libraries, not the Friends. Apparently, some people ignored warnings that only the books on the sale table could be purchased.

 

The manager of the sale, Steve McGrath, explained what had happened on a posting on the Batley Matters Facebook page, saying, “This was a book sale by The Friends of Batley Library, not Kirklees Libraries on Friday and Saturday. Friday's sale went well but Saturday's sale was sabotaged by misinformed Facebookers. Far too many people filled their bags with actual library books from the library shelves, not from the sales tables, even though I stood on the balcony, ringing a bell and constantly telling people that it was only the books on the tables that were for sale.

 

“The people who decimated the Children's library, Adult Fiction, Graphic Novels and Cookery sections of books, have actively stolen Kirklees libraries stock.

 

“This was atrocious behaviour by some who, through social media, decided that all stock was available to take regardless of my continued announcements. Even arguing and quoting the internet posts saying fill a bag for a pound.

 

“This wasn't a purge of books from a closing down library, as some used it as. It was a regular Book Sale fundraiser, to provide Batley Library events for our children and customers.

 

“People were even seen putting Lego from our Library Lego Club in their bags to take. It was like the worst of all jumble sales.

 

“I am shocked, saddened, and disappointed that this happened. People were still turning up at 4:30 onwards with bags to fill on the understanding that all books including library books were for sale. The Friends of Batley Library, not Kirklees Libraries never said that this was the case but people took it upon themselves to help themselves.

 

This is the negative power of sharing and adding your own comments on social media. That can happen, but to still continue to steal current Kirklee's stock, once informed of the actual books involved in the sale is wrong!

 

I've lost my faith in humanity slightly today. I try to do as much as I can for this wider community and although, I have been ridiculed by work professionals for my passion, I still dedicate myself to providing positive experiences for the generations.”


Posted On: 2023-11-01 09:00
User Name: PeterReynolds

Batley, in the Metropolitan Borough of Kirklees, West Yorkshire, is very much in England, and not Wales. Not everyone there comes from an British background, though many will be 2nd, 3rd, and 4th generation South Asian people, primarily of Muslim background. We're talking somewhere approaching half the population, and there is always a generation of newcomer spouses in these communities; perhaps some of those could easily and innocently misunderstand a situation like this.


Rare Book Monthly

  • Forum Auctions
    Fine Books, Manuscripts and Works on Paper
    28th May 2026
    Forum, May 28: Book of Hours.- Heures de nostre dame a l'usaige de Romme, Paris, Antoine Chappiel pour Germain Hardouin, [1504]. £6,000-8,000
    Forum, May 28: Colonna (Francesco). La Hypnerotomachia di Poliphilo, second edition, Venice, Sons of Aldus Manutius, 1545. £15,000-20,000
    Forum, May 28: The Christ Child holding a crystal orb and surrounded by banderoles with devotional exhortations, on a leaf most probably from a Book of Hours, [Southern Netherlands, last decades of the fifteenth century]. £2,000-3,000
    Forum Auctions
    Fine Books, Manuscripts and Works on Paper
    28th May 2026
    Forum, May 28: Jackson (Shirley). The Haunting of Hill House, first English edition, signed presentation inscription from the author to Claude Fredericks, 1960. £2,000-3,000
    Forum, May 28: Lennon (John). In His Own Write, first edition, first impression, signed by the author, 1964. £3,000-4,000
    Forum, May 28: Doves Press.- Keats (John). [Poems], one of 200 copies on paper, Doves Press, 1914. £5,000-7,000
    Forum Auctions
    Fine Books, Manuscripts and Works on Paper
    28th May 2026
    Forum, May 28: Rodrigues (João Barbosa). Sertum Palmarum Brasiliensium, 2 vol., first and only edition, Brussels, 1903. £8,000-12,000
    Forum, May 28: Newton (Sir Isaac). Philosophiae naturalis principia mathematica…editio ultima, auctior et emendatior, Amsterdam, Sumptibus Societatis, 1714. £8,000-12,000
    Forum, May 28: Kepler (Johannes). Ad Vitellionem paralipomena, wuibus astronomiae pars optica traditur, first edition, Frankfurt am Main, 1604. £5,000-7,000
    Forum Auctions
    Fine Books, Manuscripts and Works on Paper
    28th May 2026
    Forum, May 28: Tagliacozzi (Gaspare). De Curtorum Chirurgia per insitionem, libri duo, first edition, Venice, Gasparo Bindoni, 1597. £7,000-10,000
    Forum, May 28: Lootsman (Jacobsz). The Lightning Colomne, or Sea-Mirrour, containing the Sea-Coasts of the Northern, Eastern and Western Navigation..., 1670. £8,000-12,000
    Forum, May 28: Ribelles y Helip (José), Attributed to. An album comprising 33 finely executed watercolours of Spanish costume, bull-fighting scenes, and other genre subjects, [circa 1830]. £10,000-15,000

Article Search

Archived Articles